Watch

This lesson is about your side of the room. Adoption grief asks you to sit in something that doesn't resolve, and that's uncomfortable, and when we're uncomfortable we tend to move, usually not dramatically, but in small, caring, professional-looking ways, and three of them come from the same cultural story about adoption that everyone in this field grew up inside.

The first is gratitude. A client brings grief and you find yourself mentioning the parents who loved them. It's true, and it's warm, and it closes the subject. The second is reunion. A client grieves a mother she's never met and you hear yourself asking whether she's thought about a DNA test. It sounds like help. It can land as a push toward something she's already decided against. The third is time. A client is grieving hard at fifty and some part of you starts wondering whether this is really about the adoption, because surely that would have faded by now.

Each of those is a way of not staying. I asked an adoptee about a time a therapist couldn't stay with them. Listen for the moment it happened, and how small it was.

So the skill is catching yourself. Not never having the reaction, because you'll have it. It happens fast and it feels like care. What you're looking for is the half-second where you're about to redirect a client toward something more bearable, for them and for you.

A couple of tells. If you're proposing action, a test, a search, a step, while the client is expressing feeling, check whether they asked for a plan. If you find yourself pointing out the good things about the adoption while the client is grieving, you're probably managing your own discomfort. And if a client backs away from adoption material after you suggested something, take that seriously, because they may have concluded the topic isn't safe with you. None of this means never mention search, or never name what was good. It means letting the client set what they're working on, and noticing when it's your discomfort setting it instead.

Keep — one-page takeaway

Adoption grief rarely arrives named. It shows up inside other concerns, gets shut down before you see it, or arrives in fragments. This sheet is what to look for, what gets in the way, and what to do.

Recognizing grief that doesn't call itself grief

• Chronic low-grade sadness no specific cause explains, or depression that responds poorly to treatment.
• Circling questions about origin, biological family, or identity that can look like rumination or anxiety.
• Disproportionate responses: a film that produces days of crying, a friend's parent dying that opens far more than the relationship explains. Disproportion is often the signal.
• Material placed at the edges of a session, a DNA result or an adoption anniversary mentioned on the way out. The placement is often the client testing whether the topic belongs here.
• Somatic presentations: chest tightness, sleep disruption, chronic fatigue alongside the rest.

The three assumptions that get in the way

• Gratitude as the appropriate response. "You had parents who loved you." It may be true, and it functions to close the grief down. Let the client hold both, in their own proportions.
• Reunion as resolution. Suggesting search or DNA testing when the client hasn't asked. Reunion doesn't resolve ambiguous loss, and the client may stop bringing adoption material to avoid the suggestion.
• Time as healer. Treating grief that's active at fifty as evidence of a separate problem. Adoption grief is structurally ongoing and often intensifies with age.

Moves that work

• Name the grief lightly and let the response be information: notice aloud that this sounds like a kind of grief, then ask how that lands.
• When resistance is the disenfranchisement itself, name that gently: "You seem to pull back when I ask what you're feeling. I wonder if some part of you was told this isn't something you're supposed to feel."
• Repair small ruptures directly. With disenfranchised grief they carry more weight than they look like they should.

When the work exceeds one relationship

• Adoptee community is often the most useful referral available. It provides a witness therapy can't, and it runs alongside the work rather than replacing it.
• Consider longer-term or adoption-specialized care for late discovery within the past year, active search or reunion, intercountry placement-era learning, or grief compounding with adoptive parent death.
• Recognizing that more is needed is competent practice. Many adoptees describe years of therapy in which the grief was never reached.

Continued considerations

• Which of the three assumptions is most alive in you? You have one; the question is which.
• Think of a client who drifted away from a topic after you responded to it. What might they have concluded?
• Sit with this: what do you do with the discomfort of a client's grief, if you can't do anything with the grief itself?

↓ Download this takeaway (PDF)