Chapter 2 · Identity and Self

The abandonment alarm in the alliance

Watch

Video goes here.

We usually think of abandonment fear as something a client brings from their outside life, their relationships, their history. With adoptees it also comes into the room, into the relationship with you. And it often works like an alarm. For many adoptees the earliest separation happened before they had words for it, so the fear got laid down as a nervous-system pattern rather than a memory, a body sensation of needing to leave, a tightening, a sense of the floor dropping, that can fire in the present even when nothing in the present calls for it. It's a response to an old history rather than to anything happening between you now.

The part that's hard for us as clinicians is what tends to set it off. It's usually not a big mistake. It's a small moment, a warm comment that centered the adoptive parents, a place where the client said something hard and felt you step past it, a beat where they didn't feel seen. To an adoptee whose belonging vigilance is live, that small moment can register as a real one, and the response you see might be a pulled-back session, a cancellation, a client who was working well and then goes quiet or disappears.

This lesson is about that alarm as it shows up between you and an adopted client, and about staying steady with it, because how you handle these moments is a good part of the work itself. I asked an adoptee to talk about what that fear is like from the inside. Listen for where you feel it in your own relationships too.

So a few things to carry into the room. First, when the alarm fires, try not to read it as a verdict on you or on the therapy. A canceled session after a session that went deep is often the belonging anxiety coming online precisely because it went deep. With a lot of clients you'd read returning distance as backsliding. With adoptees, that cycling, close then far, trusting then testing, is usually the alliance being built rather than falling apart. Second, watch the small moments. Ruptures here are rarely big errors; they're the places your own assumptions about family or gratitude slipped into a sentence and landed differently than you meant. When you think one happened, you can circle back without deciding what it meant: I've been thinking about something I said last week, I want to check how it landed. That shows the client you noticed and you're willing to come back, which for someone braced to be left is its own kind of information. And third, this alliance often takes longer to build than you're used to, and that slower pace is frequently what the work requires rather than a sign it's going badly.

Reflect

Think of a time your own alarm went off over something small, a text that went unanswered longer than usual, a friend who was suddenly a little cool, a partner who seemed distant for reasons you couldn't name. Notice what happened in your body before you had any actual information, the bracing, the story that they were pulling away, maybe the urge to pull away first so it wouldn't be you left waiting.

Write one sentence about what that alarm felt like, and what you did with it.

For many adoptees that alarm was set long before there were words for it, and it can fire in the steadiest relationship, including the one they have with you. Feeling your own version of it is part of how you'll recognize it in the room without taking it personally.

Review

The therapeutic relationship is itself a belonging relationship. For an adopted client, abandonment fear doesn't stay outside the room; it can fire in the alliance with you.

  • What it is. Often laid down before words, as a nervous-system pattern from the earliest separation. It responds to old history rather than to anything present, and it shows up as body sensation (a need to leave, tightness, a dropping) as much as thought. Track the body alongside the words.
  • How it shows up in the room. The good client performing usefulness rather than being helped; the cooperative client who stays behind a wall; the client who cancels or disappears when something deepens, often right after a strong session.
  • Ruptures are usually small. Not big errors, but moments where your own assumptions about family, gratitude, or belonging slipped into a sentence and landed differently than you meant. Rejection sensitivity makes them activating.

Moves to carry:

  • Notice small moments. When you suspect one landed, circle back without deciding what it meant, and let the client tell you.
  • Don't over-respond to an exit; the repair happens in the room, not over email or text.
  • Expect cycling (close then far, trust then testing) as the alliance being built, and expect it to take longer than you're used to.

One line to remember: when an adopted client pulls back, ask what just deepened, and what small thing you might circle back to, before you read it as the work going wrong.